Build Your Own Cookie Box
Available with 3 days notice
Orderable now with advance notice.
Mix and match your favorite Penny Lane cookies. Choose a 6, 12, 24, or 36 pack and pick up to six flavors. Every cookie is about 3 oz, baked from scratch in small batches in Oak Forest, IL.
HOW PICKUP WORKS
Order at least 72 hours ahead. Your pickup spot and time depend on the day you choose:
- Monday & Tuesday, 12-5pm: 15255 S 94th Ave, Orland Park, IL 60462
- Thursday & Friday, 2-5pm: Oak Forest Police Station, 15440 Central Ave, Oak Forest, IL 60452
- Saturday, 8-10am: Oak Forest Police Station
Need an 8-9am pickup on a Monday, Tuesday, Thursday, or Friday? Just let us know when we text to confirm your pickup.
No pickups on Wednesday or Sunday. We'll text you to confirm your pickup time.
ALLERGENS
All cookies contain wheat, eggs, and milk. Chocolate Chip, Chocolate Toffee, and Cappuccino Chip also contain soy. Made in a home kitchen that may also process common food allergens.
Choose an Option
Add to Cart
Review details in your cart and choose your payment method at checkout.
We respond quickly to confirm availability, pickup details, and payment.
Prefer personal service?
Use Contact for Next Availability when you need help with:
- Coordinating delivery or pickup beyond the default options
- Shipping inquiries (when available)
- Custom designs, flavors, or dietary requests
- Large or recurring orders for events and wholesale